Mythology Matters #5 - Nart & Russian Myths - Extra Mythology

Join the Patreon community! bit.ly/EMPatreon
In this episode, we talk about the distinction between Nart and Russian myths, and how mythology is used to create the idea of shared culture between people in a large, spread-out nation.
Learn all about our shows at becauselearningmatters.com
___________
Thanks for participating in this week's discussion! We want you to be aware of our community posting guidelines so that we can have high-quality conversations: becausegamesmatter.com/extra-credits-community-code-of-conduct
Contribute community subtitles to Extra Mythology: uswork.info_cs_panel?c=UCCODtTcd5M1JavPCOr_Uydg&tab=2
Talk to us on Twitter (@ExtraCreditz): bit.ly/ECTweet
Follow us on Facebook: bit.ly/ECFBPage
___________
♪ Music: "Extra Mythology Theme" by Big Giant Circles
www.biggiantcircles.com/

Comments

  1. Extra Credits

    Extra Credits4 months ago

    Sorry, I just got back from six weeks on the road and had to do this suuuuuper late at night to get it in on time...and I sort of forgot which side the camera was on on my ipad ; ) -James Portnow

  2. john doe

    john doe2 months ago

    No one likes you.

  3. Jonathon King

    Jonathon King2 months ago

    Where's part 3 for Persian mythology

  4. I don't know

    I don't know3 months ago

    can you make a vid about the 30 years war?

  5. Hundey FuFu

    Hundey FuFu3 months ago

    @Osman Cem Uzun what are you saying?

  6. Ribbitgoesthedog Lastnamehereyeah

    Ribbitgoesthedog Lastnamehereyeah3 months ago

    @Extra Credits Please, whats your opinion about the possible connection and meaning of the Lady of the Lake of Avalon, and the ancient burials of kings and queens in the bottoms of lakes. My theory is that Excalibur is a symbol of ancestry older than roman conquest of britain, and the Lady of the Lake is no other than the ghost of last queen Boudica, whos burial place was a great secret never found.

  7. Nucky Pooh

    Nucky PoohMonth ago

    This Myths Matter episode has opened my eyes more than ever. While it’s mainly about tensions between Russia & people inhabiting North Caucasus, I (as a history fan) can somewhat relate this to various “nation-building” process in the 19th century, especially in Canada 🇨🇦. Indigenous people in Canada also once had a rich oral tradition but unfortunately the stories were largely forgotten, due to assimilation policy in the past 150 years. While certainly tensions between settlers & native tribes had existed as soon as they made contact in 1600s, most early Canadians (under British rule at the time) viewed natives as allies against a common foe - Americans, since Canada (then British North America) could potentially be annexed into USA. See Tecumseh & War of 1812. However attitude toward the natives began to change once the US-Canadian border was stabilized by mid-Victorian era. No longer seen as allies, the indigenous people in Canada were then seen as barrier to a new “Canadian identity” when the country gained autonomy from Britain in 1867. Thus beginning the tragedy for the native people in Canada.😢 Just a Canadian bear 🐻 sharing my thoughts on how contemporary issues came to be.

  8. Mario Markazi

    Mario MarkaziMonth ago

    Pre Asian =first nation is Persian is iran with are in the tribes =are nian Pre Asian =ownership of Asia like natives of America owner of America.

  9. Mario Markazi

    Mario MarkaziMonth ago

    Iran sir bull land is bull east is persppels is police east.

  10. D

    D2 months ago

    Patrons voted on Russian mythology, but you decided to do Caucasian mythology. Lol, wtf.

  11. Erin Connelly

    Erin ConnellyMonth ago

    @D: They did that after asking their Patrons. This channel is about education and telling stories, and they did an excellent job.

  12. Bobby Rehren-Zepeda

    Bobby Rehren-Zepeda2 months ago

    More Nart Saga myths please

  13. Diana J

    Diana J3 months ago

    Russia seams to be so rich of cultures, history and stories, I really need to do more research on this

  14. jonas winther

    jonas winther3 months ago

    are those dnd books on the right ? :)

  15. Jonathan Deeter

    Jonathan Deeter3 months ago

    Chechnya inherited putting LGBT people in camps from Tehran 👀🤡

  16. Imladris

    Imladris3 months ago

    Can you please cover the Welsh Mabinogion. There are some great stories in there.

  17. Mathieu Leader

    Mathieu Leader3 months ago

    Russian myths is a big tent

  18. Quinten Whyte

    Quinten Whyte3 months ago

    im getting worried about Zal & his wife and kid...

  19. Samuel Schönenberger

    Samuel Schönenberger3 months ago

    Mythology matters could be the most important part of Extra Mythology

  20. Tusk

    Tusk3 months ago

    Theres also a lot of oil in the caucasus

  21. I don't know

    I don't know3 months ago

    can you make a vid about the 30 years war?

  22. Ocearno

    Ocearno3 months ago

    Something very interesting is happening off screen

  23. Victor Carroll

    Victor Carroll3 months ago

    Не понял

  24. AGuyWithAChannel

    AGuyWithAChannel3 months ago

    Baba Yaga! Baba Yaga! *BABA YAGA!*

  25. Emily Nathali Contreras Vivas

    Emily Nathali Contreras Vivas3 months ago

    you guys are awesome!!

  26. YonYonYon

    YonYonYon3 months ago

    Would you be interested in other non-Slavic cultures from Russia? Not many people even in Russia realize that there are a lot of Asian cultures in Russia, I’m from one of them and I could translate local fairy tales and folk lore

  27. Aidan Klobuchar

    Aidan Klobuchar3 months ago

    Ooooo, nice Invisibles omnibus.

  28. Philip Hernandez

    Philip Hernandez3 months ago

    U look crazy af

  29. thou ist

    thou ist3 months ago

    You think the north and south of Italy have big cultural divides, then you haven't seen the north and south of england. The northerners say hello to random strangers on the streets and talk to people on the tube!

  30. Cule Chick

    Cule Chick3 months ago

    Thank you for educating me.

  31. Morgen Peschke

    Morgen Peschke3 months ago

    Extra Folklore? Please?

  32. Alex The Only

    Alex The Only3 months ago

    Make videos from myths from India and far east Journey to West Romance of three Kingdoms (novel not history whih you covered)

  33. 47 1776

    47 17763 months ago

    Please*

  34. Earl McCay

    Earl McCay3 months ago

    Look at me beotch

  35. Adrian Duran

    Adrian Duran3 months ago

    A Russian Mythology episode that wasn't Russian and wasn't Mythology

  36. Maximinius Thrax

    Maximinius Thrax3 months ago

    4 future reference. When ever I see this dudes ugly mug in the thumbnail, im not clicking.

  37. Conor Murphy

    Conor Murphy3 months ago

    I keep tilting the screen but he never looks me in the eye.

  38. giulliano molina

    giulliano molina3 months ago

    I love the show, and was interested in studying more about nationalism and myths. What books did you use in this episode? Which ones do you recomend?

  39. TsukiraAquarius

    TsukiraAquarius3 months ago

    So then, what would be the distinction between fairy tales and folklore(/popular antiquities)?

  40. G4all

    G4all3 months ago

    baba yaga

  41. Marcus Frowerk

    Marcus Frowerk3 months ago

    Thank you for the explanations of Myth, Folklore, and how Russia tried to redact his own folklorish past. But.. What I really would love to hear is another deepdive in these myth - what cultural background is there in the apples and seefolk and warlock and and and. Looking forward! Cheers!

  42. Wm. Max Abramowitz

    Wm. Max Abramowitz3 months ago

    Extra Credit is Great!

  43. Rosherus

    Rosherus3 months ago

    Svarog's legacy is calling, i'm accept this call, since i'm a SLAV by blood, the real BOGATYR you should read this with that one accent

  44. pspdude231

    pspdude2313 months ago

    Baba yaga. Aka john wick (known body county of 299 in the 3 movies)

  45. Oxtocoatl

    Oxtocoatl3 months ago

    The study of history suffered the same Nationalist treatment in the 19th century. Much of our popular understanding of history is a result of nationalist mythmaking. Many school curriculums still more or less are framed as "Let's tell the history of this nation"

  46. pspdude231

    pspdude2313 months ago

    Inb4 the kgb takes over extra credits

  47. Emerald Queen

    Emerald Queen3 months ago

    Vampire? You mean Warlock?

  48. Timothy Heimbach

    Timothy Heimbach3 months ago

    They're kind of the same/similar in Russian mythology

  49. Moritami Kamikara

    Moritami Kamikara3 months ago

    Freedom for all peoples. A Nation for all peoples. NART INDEPENDENCE

  50. Moritami Kamikara

    Moritami Kamikara3 months ago

    Cultural assimilation should happen... When the people are going into a different land The Narts aren't going anywhere, their land belongs to them! The Russians have no right to be imposing their culture and their law on this region which is not theirs.

  51. Arturo Reyes Cortez

    Arturo Reyes Cortez3 months ago

    Russia has serious issues about xenophobia. Also, there's the extreme weather, the poverty caused by the USSR and the current political corruption. It's no wonder why their myths involve scary evil monsters that seem like something from Warhammer 40K.

  52. Artur M.

    Artur M.3 months ago

    Yeah, the problem with the actual Slavic mythology is that there is no equivalent of the Norse Prose and Poetic Edda or the four great cycles of Irish mythology (not mentioning Homer and Hesiod). The written sources about the pre-Christian gods and beliefs are fragmentary. There is of course rich later folklore but it's hardly consistent and there's not much there about the genealogy of major gods or epic tale, with them in major roles. Everything is like an incomplete jigsaw puzzle where some pieces might even be from different sets or be completely fake (like the "Chernobog" popularised by the American Gods). Basically, everything beside basic stuff like Perun being the very important thunder god is uncertain and the subject of debates. This might actually be an interesting material for an episode but it would have to be done in a different format than the rest of Extra Mythology.

  53. jakov povreslo

    jakov povreslo3 months ago

    veles>anyone else

  54. next_ghost

    next_ghost3 months ago

    Chernobog is mentioned in Chronica Slavorum, written in 1171, back when Pomeranian Slavs were still being converted to Christianity.

  55. FelixFonRihhofen

    FelixFonRihhofen3 months ago

    By this logic you need to made an Ainu Myths in japanese episode when! I mean, almoust every country have minorities, but you kinda put russians on the spot here...

  56. HenshinFanatic

    HenshinFanatic3 months ago

    Definitely, all cultures are fascinating. I 100% expect more of these minority culture myths for pretty much every folkloric group they do.

  57. Moritami Kamikara

    Moritami Kamikara3 months ago

    Oh yeah. Ainu mythology pls.

  58. Communist Doggo

    Communist Doggo3 months ago

    its all about that sweet sweet OIL

  59. Frederick Kue

    Frederick Kue3 months ago

    James should do more voice overs, love his voice.

  60. James Vann

    James Vann3 months ago

    Just binged a bunch of episodes, and the link between Nart and Persian myths got me thinking about Zals white hair and the effects of the apples of the golden tree, and how they could interconnect

  61. Turgay McBride

    Turgay McBride3 months ago

    Bingo!

  62. Дмитрий Фролов

    Дмитрий Фролов3 months ago

    So you basically lied to promote your point of view that russia shouldn't control this area.

  63. Moritami Kamikara

    Moritami Kamikara3 months ago

    Well, Russia shouldn't control this area, that's just a fact. Also, when exactly did he lie? It's not like these myths he told aren't real and he just made them up.

  64. 2500 subs with videos?

    2500 subs with videos?3 months ago

    Mythology: its a greek term for not real gods

  65. Derek Skelton

    Derek Skelton3 months ago

    Which is why we use it for all gods...

  66. Fusel

    Fusel3 months ago

    I still think you look like the love child of Snape and keanu reeves...

  67. denalihedgehog

    denalihedgehog3 months ago

    And Serj Tankian

  68. MagnuMagnus

    MagnuMagnus3 months ago

    James? James! *snaps finger* Over here!

  69. Magnus Peacock

    Magnus Peacock3 months ago

    No, over here! ;)

  70. Jayfrid

    Jayfrid3 months ago

    Watching this felt like a 2 hour video and I got a little lost waiting for you to get to the point and now I don't what you saying

  71. Avijit Bahadur

    Avijit Bahadur3 months ago

    Sir i am great fan of ur channel, i have a request.... i m from india n if u can make any videos related to indian rulers, hindu rulers, i will be glad... Ur stories related to different kingdoms n rulers are fantabulous sir I hope u will pay concern to my topics Carry on sir... Hatss offf to u bro

  72. Derek Skelton

    Derek Skelton3 months ago

    They only take requests from patrons. You gotta support them on patreon if you want to see them to do something specific

  73. Vitaliy Bakal

    Vitaliy Bakal3 months ago

    There is a common archetype of an older wise soldier who passes throught village. Why is he old? Well, service lasted 25 years so that guy who beat warlock went as mandatory landlord household quota at 20-30. He is supposed to be at least 45, serving 20 years at some remote outpost or war.

  74. Oxtocoatl

    Oxtocoatl3 months ago

    The archetype reminds me a lot of the witcher.

  75. V, Roche

    V, Roche3 months ago

    Incoherrent rambling with the message "Russia is BAD mkay???"

  76. Кирилл Николаев

    Кирилл Николаев3 months ago

    Early Soviet Russia ,for the most part, didnt suppres non-religios mythos and fairytales, internationalism was a thing and cultural diversity was promoted to the point of delegates in parliament siting in national attires. Only religion allowed to propagate was communism tho. Change from Pagap Mythos to Cristianity was kinda intresting too, it took 600 years and old gods became monsters, pagan trinity Triglav became three headed dragon. Baba Yaga and Koshei were old gods too....

  77. Angel Fox

    Angel Fox3 months ago

    Didn't Lenin support the national determination of the people of the Cacuses?

  78. Akaking მაქაცარია

    Akaking მაქაცარია3 months ago

    You should make Caucasian mythology series! Its a distinct world between Europe and Asia with dozens of unique cultures within it!

  79. DLAlucard

    DLAlucard3 months ago

    Hey very interesting as ever mate, but do get some rest. You sound shattered.

  80. Maxim Preobrazhenskiy

    Maxim Preobrazhenskiy3 months ago

    In seeking to represent a minority you have misrepresented a russian majority. Nord myths are cool, but they are not my myths. Shame, was really looking toward your take on a character like Mikula Selyaninovich or Solovei the Brigand

  81. Maxim Preobrazhenskiy

    Maxim Preobrazhenskiy3 months ago

    ​@LifeSucksManSure why not. However, that doesn't make their myths mine. Or mine theirs, for that matter.

  82. LifeSucksMan

    LifeSucksMan3 months ago

    You do realize they are still russian because they are part of your country, history and population

  83. Moritami Kamikara

    Moritami Kamikara3 months ago

    Aye, here here!

  84. Rich Wilson

    Rich Wilson3 months ago

    Thanks for the additional context and thoughts. I hope you recover soon.